Noah – Part 1: Eternity in Darren Aronofsky’s Heart

God has set eternity in menNoah‘s hearts. But even still man cannot discover the work God has done from beginning to end. (Ecc. 3:11)

Well, the hills are alive with the sound of musings. Fighting fundamentalists on both sides of the theological/epistemological divide are either condemning or defending the fever dream that is director and co-writer Darren Aronofsky’s take on the ultimate disaster story. Not since The Last Temptation of Christ has a film based – however loosely – on Holy Writ inspired this level of controversy, defensiveness and vitriol. And I predict that this one will have more staying power because Noah is a better film – technically speaking – than Scorsese’s tedious, rambling (but in a few moments still brilliant) exercise in cinematic heresy. Even more importantly in our “bigger is better” world, Noah is an epic, $130 million, special-effects-driven spectacle – where poor Martin had to scrape by on a comparative shoestring; a sleeping-bag movie versus Darren’s tentpole.

In Part 2 I will review Noah from a theological perspective. Artistically I would give it 3.5 out of 5 stars. But then my expectations were very, very high. I figured that if Aronofsky could produce the amazing Pi for $60K, surely he could give us a new Citizen Kane or 2001 Space Odyssey when his budget was 216.66 (note the three sixes) times that. Alas, Noah is just another example of how money can’t buy perfection..

But it still is a pretty amazing film, technically and aesthetically speaking.

But before I offer my thematic analysis in Part 2, I would like to invite my Christian readers to join me in a thought experiment.

First, to director and co-writer Darren Aronofsky’s spiritual status and baseline worldview: Much has been written about his professed atheism, with two-fisted atheists proudly claiming him as one of their premier prophets. On the other side, more than a few Christians are locking and loading on his unbelief as proof of a sinister (satanic?) conspiracy to intentionally twist the Scriptures and redemptive history as if they were some gigantic wax nose. Of particular note: Aronofsky’s glaring (or perhaps cryptic) comments about his Biblical epic being  “the least biblical biblical film ever made.” Personally, having seen The Greatest Story Ever Told, I think he is both wrong as well as perhaps being intentionally provocative.

But regardless of whatever labels Darren Aronofsky uses or are assigned him by atheists and theists alike, I don’t think he is anymore an atheist than Mark Twain was. A “Christ-haunted” artist – to use Flannery O’Connors useful descriptive – Aronofsky’s adherence to the two central tenets of anti-theism seem apparent upon closer examination: 1. He doesn’t believe in God, and 2. He hates Him. Except in his case it is not so much hatred as it is the all-too-common drive to find an impersonal substitute (which, to be sure, is a form of hatred). Like every other human (see Rom. 1:20), Aronofsky’s soul intuitively senses the overwhelming evidence for design, purpose and pattern in both the cosmos and the human “knowing” of it all. But in his innate fallenness and drive to “suppress that truth in unrighteousness” (Rom. 1:18b) in order to maintain his own autonomy (ironically like his Tubal Cain character in the movie), he has invested his considerable gifts in exploring these patterns and archetypes… but then pulling back from their Source and replacing God with an amalgam of monism, pantheism, Eastern mysticism, numerology/Kaballah, environmentalism and whatever else strikes his fancy at the moment.

Consider, for example, these excerpts from an interview he gave to ChitChatMagazine.Com concerning the aforementioned movie, Pi.

“I think we’re meant to know everything, it’s just a matter of when and how. I think this knowledge of God precludes the existence of the ego and the self and that as Max gets closer and closer to finding this universal order, his own self starts to disappear more and more. That’s the underlying conflict of the movie.”

“(When) you’re walking around the Western Wall in Jerusalem with a backpack, you get brought into religious sects that introduce you to mysticism, that show you the beauty and magic of religion, to bring you back into the fold and away from Satan. For me it didn’t quite work, because the devil has some nice toys. I did come away with some nice stories and some good ideas. That was the seed for a lot of the Kabbalah stuff in the film… There’s some stuff that would blow your mind and we brought that to Pi.”

“The film [though] in a lot of ways is anti-religion and pro-spirituality. I think a lot of religious groups often forget why and what they’re doing. Anyone who believes that they should kill in the name of God I think, has totally lost all sense of spirituality. You know, that’s not what it’s about.”

And then there is this from an interview he did with FilmMonthly.com on The Fountain, a profoundly spiritual meditation on life, love, death and transcendence.

Question: “What’s your take on God? Are you religious? Do you believe in God?”

DA: “I think the themes of The Fountain, about this endless cycle of energy and matter, tracing back to the Big Bang… The Big Bang happened, and all this star matter turned into stars, and stars turned into planets, and planets turned into life. We’re all just borrowing this matter and energy for a little bit, while we’re here, until it goes back into everything else, and that connects us all. The cynics out there laugh at this crap, but it’s true. [Laughs] The messed up thing is how distracted we are and disconnected from that connection, and the result of it is what we’re doing to this planet and to ourselves….Whatever you want to call that connection — some people would use that term God. That, to me, is what I think is holy.”

Reading this and watching his movies, it’s clear that at heart Aronofsky isn’t even close to being the crass materialist true atheism demands. He’s very interested in what lies beneath and beyond the “now” of temporal existence. Death may well not be the end – as The Fountain explored – but rather the “road to awe.” (I love this line, though as a Christian I would substitute “door” for “road” – as well as caution people that for many, that “awe” will be “awe-ful.”)

Now back to our thought experiment. Imagine yourself a missionary to a pagan land. Understanding that the “lights” of regeneration have not yet been turned on, you fully expect to find darkness and all manner of idolatry and spiritual confusion. But you also hope to find some glimmers of the light that springs from the image of God yet present deep in people’s souls; the dissonant echoes of an eternity that percolates within their hearts. What happens – or at least should happen – when you stumble across these imperfect artifacts of a paradise that has been lost? Condemn their imperfections? Throw out the embryo of truth because it has been soaked in some very dirty bath water?

Even a casual glance at Jesus’ MO (e.g. see “the woman at the well” account in John 4) or Paul’s atop Mars Hill (Acts 17: 16-34) makes it clear that to do so would be to miss the heart of God and the opportunity for the Gospel.

Now I understand there are thresholds here. A missionary to a tribe of cannibals can perhaps find an opportunity to use their manifestly satanic practices to introduce the concept of substitutionary atonement or even the Eucharist. But that doesn’t give him the liberty to sit around and observe one of their rituals. You can’t condemn something while being a passive – or worse, active – witness to it. And for that reason, I would never endorse a Christian watching a movie so utterly and irredeemably blasphemous as The Last Temptation of Christ.

But as I will argue in Part 2, Aronofsky got far more right or close to right than we should have ever expected given his spiritual and epistemological baseline. It really is not too much of a stretch to call it something of a miracle, a moment when the echoes of eternity rang surprisingly loud and true, despite whatever other thematic defects are in the film. Personally, I believe we have been given a interesting teaching moment, not unlike what Jesus and Paul experienced in John 4 and Acts 17 respectively.

Aronofsky and our broader culture are hearing the echoes, sensing the outlines of something deep and transcendent. They are seeing men walking about (literally in Aronofsky’s case) as trees (Mark 8:28). Always learning but never able to come – by themselves – to a knowledge of the truth (2 Tim. 3:7), they “cannot discover the work God has done from beginning to end.”  But by God’s grace, and with our humble, loving and measured assistance, they yet may.

10,063 Comments

  1. vivod iz zapoya rostov_enpa on January 14, 2025 at 1:21 am

    вывод из запоя цена ростов вывод из запоя цена ростов .

  2. vivod iz zapoya rostov_gyPi on January 14, 2025 at 1:18 am

    вывод. из. запоя. ростов. [url=http://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov27.ru]вывод. из. запоя. ростов.[/url] .

  3. vivod iz zapoya rostov_lxMn on January 14, 2025 at 1:16 am

    вывод из запоя на дому цена вывод из запоя на дому цена .

  4. vivod iz zapoya rostov_wxpa on January 14, 2025 at 1:08 am

    алкоголизм лечение вывод из запоя ростов [url=vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov226.ru]алкоголизм лечение вывод из запоя ростов[/url] .

  5. vivod iz zapoya rostov_myMn on January 14, 2025 at 1:03 am

    капельница на дому от запоя [url=http://www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov225.ru]капельница на дому от запоя[/url] .

  6. Jasonwek on January 14, 2025 at 12:31 am

    https://casinositeleri25.com/# casino bahis siteleri

  7. vivod iz zapoya rostov_ripa on January 14, 2025 at 12:30 am

    вывод из запоя на дому ростов недорого вывод из запоя на дому ростов недорого .

  8. vivod iz zapoya rostov_obPi on January 14, 2025 at 12:29 am

    алкоголизм лечение вывод из запоя ростов алкоголизм лечение вывод из запоя ростов .

  9. vivod iz zapoya rostov_kjMn on January 14, 2025 at 12:27 am

    срочный вывод из запоя ростов https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov225.ru/ .

  10. DavidBaifs on January 14, 2025 at 12:12 am

    https://denemebonusuverensiteler25.com/# deneme bonusu veren yeni siteler

  11. uoershmlk on January 13, 2025 at 11:36 pm

    XLM’s price hit an all-time high of $0.86 during the 2017 crypto bull run. In the following bear market, XLM’s price sank to a low of $0.03. Not long after bitcoin’s price hit a then-high of $63,500, XLM’s price reached another peak of $0.73 in May 2021. The 26th largest cryptocurrency by market cap, XLM is the native token of Stellar. In 2014, Stellar raised $35 million in an initial coin offering (ICO). And when Stellar first started, 100 billion XLMs were created with an annual inflation rate of 1%, which has since been removed. The Stellar (XLM) price today is influenced by a myriad of internal and external factors that interact in complex ways. One of the primary internal factors is Stellar’s utility in facilitating low-cost, cross-border transactions. The Stellar network uses its native digital currency, Lumens (XLM), to act as a bridge for quick and efficient currency exchange, thereby affecting the current Stellar value.
    https://nerodirectory.com/listings12937226/how-can-i-buy-ethereum-max
    For those who’ve been in the memecoin world for a while, the project’s concept should resonate, mixing familiar imagery with a fresh take on what a successful crypto journey can look like. As the presale continues, early involvement in this project may prove to be a strategic move for investors seeking something unique yet rooted in a strong meme-driven narrative. Investors who secure tokens at this stage could see a notable advantage, as the presale structure allows for maximum distribution within the community. The founders explained that those buying Shiba Inu would have the opportunity to make the same sort of gains that Dogecoin generated in early 2021. And to put it frankly – they were right. This is because Shiba Inu has increased the value of its token by millions of percentage points since it was launched.

  12. vivod iz zapoya rostov_acPi on January 13, 2025 at 11:31 pm

    вывод из запоя цены ростов-на-дону вывод из запоя цены ростов-на-дону .

  13. vivod iz zapoya rostov_lqpa on January 13, 2025 at 11:31 pm

    вывод из запоя недорого ростов вывод из запоя недорого ростов .

  14. vivod iz zapoya rostov_jtMn on January 13, 2025 at 11:29 pm

    вывод из запоя цена ростов вывод из запоя цена ростов .

  15. rqhaktocu on January 13, 2025 at 11:23 pm

    How do you feel about Ethereum Meta today? Vote to see results Discover more of Etherscan’s tools and services in one place. After summarizing the news, we’ll share perspectives from thought leaders in the crypto space. We’ll also offer the author’s own take, discuss how decentralization could impact the situation, make a prediction and draw parallels to relevant cultural events. Finally, we’ll directly answer two key questions to deliver actionable insights to readers. Ethereum Meta token is a foundation of the Anonymous E-Market Place that we are building to be also accessible by Tor Browser Acala is a prominent player in the Web3 financial space, spearheading the creation of a liquidity layer that seeks to democratize finance. This decentralized platform is not only a hub for substantial liquidity, but also a breeding ground for innovative financial applications, boasting features like an application-specific blockchain with built-in tools and continuous, seamless upgrades.
    https://metaldevastationradio.com/cryptocomisdown
    While not completely anonymous, paying with Bitcoin allows you to buy a VPN subscription outside the scope of banks and other financial institutions. The price of a subscription is pegged to the same dollar amount that you would spend otherwise and thus adjusts according to the current price of Bitcoin. In countries where Bitcoin is banned, and exchanges are censored or monitored, a VPN can help bypass these obstacles and allow you to freely trade cryptocurrencies. Popular restaurants allow customers to buy food with Bitcoin, saving them from carrying cash always and its challenges. If you have a crypto debit card, you’re even luckier because you can buy with Bitcoin at any restaurant that accepts MasterCard or Visa.  Instead of keeping your digital assets on a Bitcoin exchange, you could keep your BTC in a Bitcoin wallet. Wallets come in two forms — hot and cold. Hot wallets are software that stays connected to the internet, aka storing your Bitcoin online in a digital wallet or a mobile wallet. It is more convenient to transact via a hot wallet, but they are more susceptible to being attacked. Cold storage of your new Bitcoin is possible by using hardware wallets, but online wallets are potentially more user-friendly for crypto newbies.

  16. vivod iz zapoya rostov_yupa on January 13, 2025 at 11:09 pm

    вывод из запоя дешево ростов вывод из запоя дешево ростов .

  17. vivod iz zapoya rostov_jxPi on January 13, 2025 at 11:09 pm

    вывод из запоя в ростове вывод из запоя в ростове .

  18. vivod iz zapoya rostov_skMn on January 13, 2025 at 11:07 pm

    вывод из запоя цены на дому ростов вывод из запоя цены на дому ростов .

  19. vivod iz zapoya rostov_uapa on January 13, 2025 at 11:06 pm

    вывод из запоя стационар ростов вывод из запоя стационар ростов .

  20. vivod iz zapoya rostov_psPi on January 13, 2025 at 11:06 pm

    вывод. из. запоя. на. дому. ростов. http://www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov27.ru .

  21. vivod iz zapoya rostov_dpMn on January 13, 2025 at 11:04 pm

    вывод из запоя дешево ростов на дону vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov225.ru .

  22. Sazrosm on January 13, 2025 at 10:04 pm
  23. Sazrmfs on January 13, 2025 at 9:38 pm
  24. vivod iz zapoya rostov_iqSr on January 13, 2025 at 9:35 pm

    вывод из запоя ростов на дону вывод из запоя ростов на дону .

  25. Stamp making online_bfsr on January 13, 2025 at 9:34 pm

    create stamp online free create stamp online free .

  26. vivod iz zapoya rostov_wuPi on January 13, 2025 at 9:27 pm

    ростов вывод из запоя [url=https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov27.ru/]ростов вывод из запоя[/url] .

  27. vivod iz zapoya rostov_vhpa on January 13, 2025 at 9:27 pm

    капельница на дому от запоя [url=https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov226.ru]капельница на дому от запоя[/url] .

  28. vivod iz zapoya rostov_ydMn on January 13, 2025 at 9:26 pm

    врач на дом капельница от запоя [url=www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov225.ru]врач на дом капельница от запоя[/url] .

  29. Stamp making online_tdsr on January 13, 2025 at 9:12 pm

    stamp making online stamp making online .

  30. Stamp making online_jwsr on January 13, 2025 at 9:02 pm

    make stamp online free [url=https://stamp-creator-online0.com/]stamp-creator-online0.com[/url] .

  31. vivod iz zapoya rostov_jmSr on January 13, 2025 at 8:59 pm

    принудительный вывод из запоя ростов [url=www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov224.ru]www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov224.ru[/url] .

  32. vivod iz zapoya rostov_jaSr on January 13, 2025 at 8:42 pm

    вывод из запоя цена ростов [url=https://www.vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov224.ru]вывод из запоя цена ростов[/url] .

  33. Stamp making online_zgsr on January 13, 2025 at 8:36 pm

    online stamp maker online stamp maker .

  34. vivod iz zapoya rostov_nlSr on January 13, 2025 at 8:31 pm

    вывод. из. запоя. на. дому. ростов. https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov224.ru/ .

  35. Stamp making online_jgsr on January 13, 2025 at 7:54 pm

    online stamp maker free online stamp maker free .

  36. vivod iz zapoya rostov_gtSr on January 13, 2025 at 7:47 pm

    вывод из запоя ростов на дону вывод из запоя ростов на дону .

  37. Stamp making online_kqsr on January 13, 2025 at 7:34 pm

    make stamp online make stamp online .

  38. vivod iz zapoya rostov_btSr on January 13, 2025 at 7:26 pm

    вывод из запоя на дому ростов-на-дону вывод из запоя на дому ростов-на-дону .

  39. DavidBaifs on January 13, 2025 at 7:17 pm

    http://sweetbonanza25.com/# sweet bonanza oyna

  40. Furnitura_csor on January 13, 2025 at 7:11 pm

    Множество вариантов фурнитуры для плинтуса, выберите подходящий вам вариант.
    Надежные элементы для плинтуса, гарантия долгого срока службы.
    Легкость сборки плинтуса, без лишних усилий.
    Тренды в дизайне фурнитуры для плинтуса, сделайте дом уютным и стильным.
    Фурнитура для плинтуса из экологически чистых материалов, экологичный выбор для вашего дома.
    Тренды в оттенках для декора плинтуса, выберите подходящий вам вариант.
    Оригинальные решения для отделки плинтуса, сделайте свой дом неповторимым.
    Советы по выбору фурнитуры для плинтуса, чтобы сделать правильный выбор.
    Стильные детали для украшения плинтуса, создайте уютный и стильный дом.
    Изысканные решения для отделки плинтуса, для создания аристократичной атмосферы.
    крепежи для плинтуса https://furnituradlyaplintusamsk.ru/ .

  41. WallaceEmbep on January 13, 2025 at 6:56 pm

    deneme bonusu veren siteler: yeni deneme bonusu veren siteler – denemebonusuverensiteler25

  42. Stamp making online_vusr on January 13, 2025 at 6:03 pm

    stamp online maker [url=stamp-creator-online0.com]stamp online maker[/url] .

  43. Furnitura_jfor on January 13, 2025 at 6:03 pm

    Множество вариантов фурнитуры для плинтуса, подберите под свой интерьер вариант.
    Надежные элементы для плинтуса, долговечные и надежные в использовании.
    Легкость сборки плинтуса, сэкономьте время и силы.
    Тренды в дизайне фурнитуры для плинтуса, выделитесь из общей массы.
    Фурнитура для плинтуса из экологически чистых материалов, сделайте свой дом более безопасным для здоровья.
    Модные цвета для элементов плинтуса, подчеркните цветовую гамму своего интерьера.
    Оригинальные решения для отделки плинтуса, привнесите уникальность в интерьер.
    Рекомендации по заботе о фурнитуре для плинтуса, для безупречного результата.
    Стильные детали для украшения плинтуса, выдержите общий стиль в каждой детали.
    Элегантные элементы для стильного плинтуса, для создания аристократичной атмосферы.
    фурнитура для плинтуса https://furnituradlyaplintusamsk.ru/ .

  44. vivod iz zapoya rostov_dtSr on January 13, 2025 at 5:54 pm

    вывод из запоя цены ростов на дону [url=https://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov224.ru/]вывод из запоя цены ростов на дону[/url] .

  45. Furnitura_uvor on January 13, 2025 at 4:45 pm

    Широкий выбор фурнитуры для плинтуса, подберите под свой интерьер вариант.
    Прочные материалы для плинтуса, не подведут вас в эксплуатации.
    Удобство монтажа фурнитуры для плинтуса, для быстрой установки.
    Современные решения для отделки плинтуса, выделитесь из общей массы.
    Природные решения для отделки плинтуса, сделайте свой дом более безопасным для здоровья.
    Модные цвета для элементов плинтуса, выберите подходящий вам вариант.
    Уникальные элементы для стильного плинтуса, выразите свою индивидуальность через дизайн.
    Подсказки по правильной установке элементов плинтуса, чтобы сделать правильный выбор.
    Стильные детали для украшения плинтуса, выдержите общий стиль в каждой детали.
    Элегантные элементы для стильного плинтуса, подчеркните изысканный вкус в дизайне.
    напольные покрытия напольные покрытия .

  46. Bradleysycle on January 13, 2025 at 3:47 pm

    sweet bonanza oyna sweet bonanza slot sweet bonanza giris

  47. DavidBaifs on January 13, 2025 at 2:36 pm

    http://sweetbonanza25.com/# sweet bonanza oyna

  48. FrankJAK on January 13, 2025 at 11:39 am

    en kazancl? slot oyunlar?: en cok kazand?ran slot oyunlar? – en kazancl? slot oyunlar?

  49. vivod iz zapoya rostov_zkPi on January 13, 2025 at 6:12 am

    вывод из запоя в стационаре ростова [url=http://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov27.ru]http://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov27.ru[/url] .

  50. vivod iz zapoya rostov_tdpa on January 13, 2025 at 6:11 am

    клиника вывод из запоя ростов [url=http://vyvod-iz-zapoya-rostov226.ru]клиника вывод из запоя ростов[/url] .

Leave a Comment